CASE LAW · LEGAL PRECEDENT

Documented cases & legal precedent.

Court-documented cases where low-frequency noise and infrasound led to convictions, nuisance findings, and shutdowns — with named counsel, the legal landscape by country, and the sources behind each one.

Compiled by LF Research · Updated October 23, 2026 · Links checked at compile time

The short version

Deliberately aiming bass at a neighbor does get people convicted — but under general harassment, stalking, or noise-nuisance laws. No country covered here has a specific "low-frequency" offense. Companies that cause low-frequency noise mostly lose civil nuisance suits rather than face criminal charges.

The weak spot everywhere is measurement: standard A-weighted (dBA) meters under-read bass, so logs, recordings, and expert surveys usually decide these cases.

This page summarizes publicly reported cases for research and educational purposes. It is not legal advice. For attorneys by practice area, see the Legal Directory.

Key takeaways

Deliberate bass harassment can be prosecuted

A Florida woman was charged with aggravated stalking for it. South Korea's Supreme Court ruled in December 2023 that deliberate noise can be stalking. UK councils prosecute people who break noise abatement orders and seize their speakers.

Courts don't require a decibel threshold

In Godfrey v Conwy, a UK court found a nuisance without any particular dB level. Courts in Ireland and Massachusetts shut down wind turbines on residents' testimony and recordings, even though operators said they met planning limits.

Data centers & bitcoin mines are the big new source

Residents in Granbury, TX beat a motion to dismiss in their nuisance suit, though criminal noise citations there failed. Prince William County, VA switched to dB(C) limits, which pick up the bass that dB(A) misses.

The science is mixed

Low-frequency noise clearly causes annoyance and lost sleep. Direct health harm from infrasound (below 20 Hz) at typical levels isn't established. A July 2026 study suggests many cases of "the Hum" may be low-frequency tinnitus.

Key cases (court-documented)

Fourteen cases with a documented outcome, plus two still pending at the allegation stage.

State v. Marianna Seachrist

Orlando, FL · 2015–19

Speakers mounted face-down on her condo floor, weighted with cinder blocks, switched on and off by remote.

Outcome: Charged with aggravated stalking; found guilty of stalking (2019); affirmed on appeal 2020.

Sources: FOX 35 WSOC

Korea Supreme Court, Gimhae case (2023도10313)

South Korea · Dec 14, 2023

31 early-morning noise episodes aimed at the upstairs family, who kept a daily log and video.

Outcome: 8 months, suspended for 2 years. The first top-court ruling that noise can be stalking.

Daejeon "woofer couple"

South Korea · 2022

A woofer mounted on their ceiling played household noises and "ghost sounds" into the unit upstairs 10 times.

Outcome: ₩7M fine.

Source: Yonhap TV

Daejeon District Court (2024고정156)

South Korea · 2022 acts

A bone-conduction woofer sent hammering, drilling, and hum sounds upstairs 41 times.

Outcome: Convicted of stalking and a noise offense; fined ₩10M, reduced on appeal; speaker confiscated.

Source: LFind

Slough BC v. Harpreet Bal

UK · 2023–25

Amplified music; broke an abatement notice 8 times.

Outcome: Harassment conviction: 12 weeks suspended, restraining order, subwoofer and soundbars forfeited.

Bradford v. Imre Lakatos

UK · 2023–26

"Dominant bass beat"; the council took 38 recordings over 7 days.

Outcome: £1,500 fine plus costs (his 2nd conviction); speakers seized under a warrant.

Source: GB News

Godfrey v Conwy CBC

UK High Court · 2000

Bass from a band studio 180 m away.

Outcome: Nuisance proven without any dB threshold.

Source: BAILII

Night & Day Café v Manchester CC

UK · 2021–24

Abatement notice for "excessively loud music and bass."

Outcome: Upheld; the venue must fit sealed sound limiters.

Enfield LBC v Beckford

UK High Court · 2025

Appeal over a noise abatement notice.

Outcome: The council won. The High Court held that an abatement notice can simply require the noise to be abated without listing the steps to take, so the resident's challenge to the notice failed.

Webster v Meenacloghspar (Wind) Ltd

Ireland High Court · 2024–25

A wind turbine's pulsing "thump."

Outcome: Nuisance found; turbine ordered off at night; damages awarded (payment paused pending appeal; injunction still in force).

Town of Falmouth v. ZBA

Massachusetts · 2017

Neighbors' health complaints about two town wind turbines.

Outcome: Ruled a nuisance and ordered shut down; the town didn't appeal.

Citizens Concerned About Wolf Hollow v. Marathon / MARA

Hood County, TX · filed Oct 2024

Low-frequency fan noise and vibration from a bitcoin mine.

Outcome: Motion to dismiss denied (2025); case ongoing.

Texas v. David Fischer (Marathon site manager)

Hood County · July 2024

Constable's citations for readings above 85 dB.

Outcome: Jury acquitted; personal responsibility wasn't proven.

Source: WFAA

Edrei v. City of New York (LRAD)

NYC · 2014 protests, settled 2021

Police used an LRAD "sound cannon" alert tone on protesters.

Outcome: Painful tone banned; $98k to plaintiffs plus $650k in fees.

Source: AP

Demers v. Digi Power X — allegation stage

New York · pending

A class action over bitcoin-mine fans, alleging "low-frequency sound that manifests like vibrations." Not yet decided.

Source: Complaint

Valenzuela et al. v. Alliance Cloud Services, LLC — pending

W.D. Mich. · filed May 2026

Proposed federal class action by residents near a data center in Dowagiac, Michigan, operated by Alliance Cloud Services (a Hyperscale Data subsidiary). The complaint alleges inadequate soundproofing and that constant noise from the facility interferes with residents' use of their homes. Not yet decided.

Attorneys & firms

Counsel of record where it is publicly reported. See the brief for attorneys and the Legal Directory for practitioners by area.

Firms & counsel worth knowing

Earthjustice (Gulf Regional Office) — the main nonprofit representing residents against bitcoin-mine noise in Texas.

Weitz & Luxenberg — a large plaintiffs' firm now bringing crypto-mine noise nuisance claims in New York.

Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough — MARA's regular defense firm.

Gill & Brissette (Fort Worth) — won the acquittal on the Texas criminal noise charges.

Kings Chambers (Sarah Clover, Leo Charalambides) — UK specialists in licensing and statutory nuisance.

Noonan Linehan Carroll Coffey, with John Rogers SC — won the Irish wind-farm noise case for the neighbors.

Stokoe Partnership — instructed for the resident (Beckford), whose challenge to the abatement notice failed.

Christopher G. Senie — Massachusetts lawyer for the neighbors of the Falmouth wind turbines.

Elena Cohen and Gideon Orion Oliver — civil-rights counsel on the NYPD sound-cannon (LRAD) case.

Counsel by case

Wolf Hollow residents v. Marathon / MARA (TX)

Residents: Earthjustice (Rodrigo Cantú, Rebecca Ramirez, Jennifer Powis, Meghan Riley). MARA: Nelson Mullins (Robert Thackston, Paula Pendley, Tanya Scarbrough, Kurt Greve).

MARA v. Hood County (N.D. Tex., dismissed Dec 2025)

MARA: Nelson Mullins. County: County Attorney Matthew Mills, Arturo Martinez de Vara (Martinez De Vara Law Firm), Charles Sierra.

Texas v. David Fischer

Prosecution: Hood County Attorney Matt Mills. Fischer: Gill & Brissette, Fort Worth (Bob Gill, Miles Brissette).

Demers v. Digi Power X (W.D.N.Y., pending)

Plaintiffs: Weitz & Luxenberg (James Bilsborrow, Emma Dietz, Robin Greenwald, Devin Bolton, Robert Quigley). Digi Power X: Matthew Bird (firm unconfirmed).

Webster v Meenacloghspar Wind (Ireland)

Neighbors: John Rogers SC, instructed by Noonan Linehan Carroll Coffey (solicitor Philip Coffey). Operator: not publicly reported.

Enfield LBC v Beckford (2025)

Council: Andrew Price. Beckford: Jonathan Powell, instructed by Stokoe Partnership.

Night & Day Café v Manchester CC

Venue: Sarah Clover (Kings Chambers). Council: Leo Charalambides (Kings Chambers).

Bradford v Lakatos

For the council: Waseem Raja. Defendant: none; sentenced in his absence.

Edrei v. City of New York (LRAD)

Protesters: Elena Cohen and Gideon Orion Oliver. City: NYC Law Department (Corporation Counsel James E. Johnson, ACC Peter Brocker).

Seachrist v. State (Fla. 5th DCA, 2020)

State: AG Ashley Moody's office (AAG Allison Morris). Seachrist: Public Defender James Purdy's office (APD Kathryn Radtke).

Falmouth wind turbines (MA)

2017 trial counsel not reported. In the earlier Drummey v. Falmouth (2015), the neighbors had Christopher Senie; Town Counsel Frank Duffy Jr.

Stories behind the cases

Granbury, TX (TIME, July 2024): More than 40 residents described migraines, vertigo, tinnitus, and lost sleep. Their evidence ranged from phone apps (one mother logged 72 dB in her daughter's bedroom at night) to a constable's cheap meter used over about six months. A county-commissioned study measured only 35–53 dBA at homes — a vivid example of how A-weighting hides bass. Health causation is the residents' belief and isn't proven.

Great Oak, Manassas, VA (Semafor, 2025): After Amazon swapped the fans on its data centers, residents said the sound dropped in pitch and started rattling dishes and frames, which pushed the county toward a new ordinance.

Falmouth, MA: The judge found plaintiff Barry Funfar credible that the turbines significantly worsened his insomnia, anxiety, and nausea; he moved away part of the year to escape them.

Omagh, Northern Ireland (Guardian, Nov 2023): A town-wide hum led the council to look into specialist detection equipment. No source was found.

Windsor Hum (CBC): A rare hum with a confirmed source. It stopped in 2020 when U.S. Steel idled its Zug Island plant.

Recent developments (2020–2026)

Oct 28, 2025: Prince William County, VA passed a dB(C) data-center noise ordinance (73 day / 68 night), effective May 1, 2026. Residents called the limits too weak (Bristow Beat / InsideNoVa).

Jan 2025: Most US intelligence agencies said it's "very unlikely" a foreign adversary caused Havana syndrome, though two partly disagreed (ODNI). NIH studies in 2024 found no MRI-detectable brain injury (NIH).

July 2026: An NTNU study (PLOS One) suggests most people who hear "the Hum" have low-frequency tinnitus (ScienceDaily).

The legal landscape

United States

There's effectively no federal remedy; the Noise Control Act of 1972 lost its funding. Limits are set by states and cities. Texas's 85 dB criminal threshold is among the loudest; NYC caps some noise at 42 dB inside the affected home.

Routes: local ordinance complaints; private nuisance suits for an injunction and/or damages (Granbury, Falmouth); stalking or harassment charges when the noise is deliberate and targeted (Seachrist); HOA or condo enforcement.

Measurement problem: most ordinances use dB(A), which strips out bass. The trend is toward dB(C) or octave-band limits. Enforcement can also stall on who is personally liable (the Texas acquittal).

United Kingdom (England & Wales)

Under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 s.79–80, councils must investigate complaints and serve an abatement notice when they find a statutory nuisance (GOV.UK). Breaching a notice is a criminal offense, and equipment can be seized.

A notice can simply order the noise abated without listing steps (Enfield v Beckford [2025] EWHC 1218). The Protection from Harassment Act and Community Protection Notices are also used. Under s.82, individuals can bring a private complaint to magistrates.

DEFRA NANR45 (Salford, 2011) is a reference curve for 10–160 Hz third-octave bands, checked against the complainant's log — guidance, not a legal threshold (PDF). Councils admit LF noise is hard to investigate because ordinary meters may not register it (Torridge DC).

Ireland

A private nuisance claim can win even when the source complies with planning guidance, and courts will order operating restrictions (Webster).

South Korea

The Stalking Punishment Act covers deliberate, repeated noise, with penalties up to 3 years in prison or a ₩30M fine.

The science, briefly

  • • At equal dB(A) levels, bass-heavy noise is judged 4–7 dB louder and 5–8 dB more annoying, and people vary a lot in sensitivity (Leventhall review, PubMed).
  • • Low-frequency sound travels further and passes through walls and windows better than higher frequencies. It's often more noticeable indoors and at night, and its source is hard to locate.
  • • Australia's NHMRC (2015) found no consistent evidence that wind farms directly harm health, including via infrasound (NHMRC). Chronic noise and sleep loss, however, are established stressors.
  • • "Targeted individuals": a large online community believes it is being attacked with sound or "frequency" weapons. Psychiatrists quoted by the NYT (2016) say these forums can reinforce delusional thinking. None of the verified cases above involved covert weapons; they involved ordinary speakers, fans, and turbines.

If you're affected: practical steps

  1. 1. Keep a log: date, time, duration, which room, how it felt, and what it stopped you doing. Courts and NANR45 rely heavily on logs.
  2. 2. Record it with the right tool. Phones capture bass badly. Use a meter that does dB(C)/dB(Z) or octave bands, or ask the city or council to install its own monitoring.
  3. 3. Rule out your own home first (boiler, fridge, pumps), and check whether others in your household hear it. If only you hear it, everywhere you go, get a hearing check for low-frequency tinnitus.
  4. 4. Escalate step by step: a letter, then a city or council complaint, then a citation or abatement notice (or a UK s.82 private complaint).
  5. 5. If it's clearly deliberate and aimed at you (speakers pointed at a shared wall or floor, timed to your presence), report it to police as harassment or stalking, with photos and any messages.
  6. 6. For industrial sources, pool complaints with neighbors, hire an acoustic consultant who measures in dB(C) and octave bands, and consult a nuisance lawyer. Groups like Earthjustice take community cases.

These are publicly reported cases, compiled for research. If you know of a documented case we've missed, or a correction, we'd like to hear it.

Share your story